Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Monday, January 21, 2008 | Reason : Religion as Child Abuse | print version Print | Comments

Document The devilish church practice of exorcism

by Johann Hari

Reposted from:
http://comment.independent.co.uk/commentators/johann_hari/article3345137.ece

Last year, I met a drawn, defeated 14-year old girl who had been possessed by Satan, until he and his Armies of Evil were tortured out of her.

That is how her priest explained it to me. That is how she explained it to me.

They spoke as if it was all as obvious as her scars. Clarice was a tiny girl wrapped in a big white woollen cardigan. In a church in the middle of Congo's carnage she explained how she had chosen to let the demons enter her when she was twelve.

Since then, Satan had forced her to make her mother fall, breaking her leg.

Satan had forced her to jinx her father, making it impossible for him to get a job. Satan had forced her to kill her little sister, by giving her a deadly fever.

Her Pentecostalist priest, Papa Enoch Boonga, told me with pride how he had driven the demons out. They starved Clarice for four days, whipped her and threatened to burn her, until finally she "confessed."

Then they forced her to admit to everything she had done, and performed a long exorcism ceremony. They only believed it was working when her little body began to judder and howl and curse. I ask Clarice quietly if she really believed she had done all these things. "Yes," she said. "I do." And so we sigh lazily: another example of African primitivism. But no. Exorcism, even of children, is being aggressively promoted today by one of the most powerful men in the Western world, Pope Benedict XVI, in only slightly watered-down form. Presidents and Prime Ministers fawn over this man.

His every word is reported with the respect we are required to show to "religion", lest we are accused of bigotry.

And yet he is openly commanding an army of exorcists to tell horrifically disturbed and mentally ill people that demons and devils are within them – because they invited evil in.

This December, Father Gabriele Amorth, official exorcist of the Rome Diocese, and friend of the "Holy Father", announced that the Pope will soon undertake a new campaign to unleash a fresh batch of 400 exorcists on the world, in addition to the thousands already in operation. "Thank God," he said, "we have a Pope who has decided to confront the devil head-on." (One representative of this evil, he added, is Harry Potter.)

The Catholic Church has officially denied having such a plan – but they admit the Church has had official exorcism rites since 1614, and that bishops and priests are encouraged to act on them today "where appropriate."

In practice, official Catholic exorcisms have been dramatically increasing since the mid-1970s, according to Michael W. Cuneo, a sociologist at Fordham University in New York who conducted a four-year study into this topic. But very few people were prepared to talk to me about what this involves.

I was finally able to track down one of the more "moderate" exorcists – if you can imagine such a thing – in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Hallam, in Yorkshire.

Father Anthony Hayne is a soft-spoken, sincere man who tells me that in his little slice of Britain he carries out "a couple of exorcisms a month".

Although it's years since he's seen the movie The Exorcist, he thinks it's broadly accurate, explaining, "As a Catholic, I would use those methods, yes.

"Lately I've been seeing a professional person who seems very balanced, except she feels demons are ruining her life. Sometimes she speaks with a voice that is certainly not her voice, it is obviously a demon using her. . . We have prayed together, and if that doesn't work we have a solemn rite of exorcism we can use if we have the approval of the bishop."

He says he takes the question of whether these people are mentally ill "very seriously".

He encourages anybody who feels they are possessed to go to their doctor – but he claims he has to take their word for it when they say the doctor says there is no physical or psychological cause for their disturbance, because of patient confidentiality.

Father Anthony tells me he does indeed believe children can be possessed, although he would only ever "treat" a child with the presence and co-operation of its parents. The closest he has come is to treat a few people in their late teens, who "had been using ouija boards and had let the darkness into their lives".

It's true the official Catholic exorcism rites do not involve the physical torture inflicted on Clarice – but in many cases, it inevitably involves telling the mentally ill they are responsible for their own suffering.

For example, one of the heroes to Catholic exponents of exorcism is M. Scott Peck, who wrote: "People who are suffering from demonic possession [have] at some level co-operated with demonic evil; they have invited it into their life. In such cases there is always – perhaps at an unconscious level – some kind of sell-out to evil." Imagine telling this to a howling woman hearing voices. Every day there is a case somewhere of an exorcist taking the Catholic theology seriously but going beyond its fetid rules. To pluck one recent example from hundreds: recently a 23-year-old Romanian nun called Maricica Irina Cornici became convinced she was hearing the voice of Satan.

Her colleagues reacted by tying her to a cross, gagging her mouth with a towel, and leaving her for three days with no food or water, to "starve out Satan". At the inquest, it was revealed she had a long history of schizophrenia. Whenever I write about the harm caused by organised superstition, well-meaning people write, asking – why get so worked up? Isn't religion all about love and light and helping people through the hard times?

No. Here is the biggest, richest and most powerful religious institution on earth, explicitly telling deeply mentally ill people the Devil is within them because they asked him in, and they have to suffer to get him out. Even the famously wet and woolly Church of England has an official exorcist in every diocese. This is not love, nor light.

Nor can we fall back on the glib claim that these people are distorting the "true" religion, which is all about peace and love. Jesus Christ himself performed exorcisms and he called on his followers to copy him, engaging in spiritual trench warfare against Satan. If a Christian is somebody who follows the example of Christ, these people are true and good Christians – and they are also deeply immoral human beings.

In that crater-church in Congo, I wanted to be able to hug Clarice, and tell her that there was a place in the world where these barbaric superstitions were a distant, dismissed relic. Thanks to the Catholic Church, I could not offer her even that.

Comments 1 - 50 of 51 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

1. Comment #114073 by liberalartist on January 21, 2008 at 10:17 am

 avatarOnce again the Catholic church leads the way in human denigration. When will rational people wake up to the barbaric practices of their so-called religions?!

Other Comments by liberalartist

2. Comment #114074 by gd_edi on January 21, 2008 at 10:20 am

 avatarMakes my stomach turn. It really is insane that this kind of stuff still goes on in today's world.

Other Comments by gd_edi

3. Comment #114075 by Pilot22A on January 21, 2008 at 10:21 am

I am an old man now, but I will never forget the terror I felt as a child, going to bed on Sunday nights, after a day in church, and being frightened to go to sleep because I was sure the devil was going to take my "soul" because of some childhood error I had made.

I have never hated, except for religion and the despicable religious people who profited and profit from terrorizing others.

Other Comments by Pilot22A

4. Comment #114080 by DarwinsPitbull on January 21, 2008 at 10:33 am

Say what you want about this story but at least they got the devil out of her. Theres nothing more scarier then having made up imaginary demons in you.

Other Comments by DarwinsPitbull

5. Comment #114083 by konquererz on January 21, 2008 at 10:42 am

 avatarThat "exorcism" of that little girl was cruel, immoral, and should be criminal! Beat and whipped her until she confessed? That priest and her parents need to have the exact same exorcism!

Other Comments by konquererz

6. Comment #114094 by GBG on January 21, 2008 at 11:13 am

 avatarI usually like to have a good laugh at the religious, What with them being complete cretins and all. But this kind of stuff makes me absolutely furious. I resent having to read the abuse that religious scum gets away with and not being able get a stick of my own and start beating on some real demons.

Other Comments by GBG

7. Comment #114096 by BicycleRepairMan on January 21, 2008 at 11:17 am

 avatar
It really is insane that this kind of stuff still goes on in today's world.


Couldnt agree more, let me just recommend that you read "Infidel" by Ayaan Hirsi Ali, it gave me a much better understanding of exactly how tribalized and ignorant parts of Africa is..and how Islam especially makes everything worse.

In one passage of the book, from about 1980 or so, Ayaan comes home from school and tells her mother that people had gone to the moon. Her mother called bullshit: "the kristaan (Christians ie: every non-muslim) go to the top of the mountain and thinks that theyve reached the moon!" she said, and told her not to believe such lies. This was in 1980 or so.

Other Comments by BicycleRepairMan

8. Comment #114097 by SteveN on January 21, 2008 at 11:19 am

 avatarI felt physically sick reading how that smug, deluded idiot of a priest "told me with pride how he had driven the demons out. They starved Clarice for four days, whipped her and threatened to burn her, until finally she "confessed."

In any other situation he and the parents would be sent to jail, but because it's the church they can boast to the press about the suffering they inflicted on an innocent child and nobody will do a thing about it.

Bloody hell, it makes me sooooo mad!

Other Comments by SteveN

9. Comment #114108 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:39 am

I think that besides being resposible for all the listed misfortunes of her family that it is about just as likely that her possesion by a demon is also resposible for global warming, the Palistinian homeland problem,the lack of the proper amount of respect I am getting at work, and any number of other problems. God, I am glad all that has been delt w/ in a reasonable manner and we can all go on w our lives now not having to deal w any of those issues.

Other Comments by babrock

10. Comment #114109 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:39 am

I think that besides being resposible for all the listed misfortunes of her family that it is about just as likely that her possesion by a demon is also resposible for global warming, the Palistinian homeland problem,the lack of the proper amount of respect I am getting at work, and any number of other problems. God, I am glad all that has been delt w/ in a reasonable manner and we can all go on w our lives now not having to deal w any of those issues.

Other Comments by babrock

11. Comment #114110 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:39 am

I think that besides being resposible for all the listed misfortunes of her family that it is about just as likely that her possesion by a demon is also resposible for global warming, the Palistinian homeland problem,the lack of the proper amount of respect I am getting at work, and any number of other problems. God, I am glad all that has been delt w/ in a reasonable manner and we can all go on w our lives now not having to deal w any of those issues.

Other Comments by babrock

12. Comment #114111 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:40 am

I think that besides being resposible for all the listed misfortunes of her family that it is about just as likely that her possesion by a demon is also resposible for global warming, the Palistinian homeland problem,the lack of the proper amount of respect I am getting at work, and any number of other problems. God, I am glad all that has been delt w/ in a reasonable manner and we can all go on w our lives now not having to deal w any of those issues.

Other Comments by babrock

13. Comment #114112 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:40 am

I think that besides being resposible for all the listed misfortunes of her family that it is about just as likely that her possesion by a demon is also resposible for global warming, the Palistinian homeland problem,the lack of the proper amount of respect I am getting at work, and any number of other problems. God, I am glad all that has been delt w/ in a reasonable manner and we can all go on w our lives now not having to deal w any of those issues.

Other Comments by babrock

14. Comment #114114 by babrock on January 21, 2008 at 11:42 am

oops

Other Comments by babrock

15. Comment #114119 by AshtonBlack on January 21, 2008 at 11:53 am

 avatar
They starved Clarice for four days, whipped her and threatened to burn her, until finally she "confessed."


Sick Fucks.

Other Comments by AshtonBlack

16. Comment #114123 by Radesq on January 21, 2008 at 12:00 pm

 avatarWho was Clarice's priest again, Hannibal Lecter?

Other Comments by Radesq

17. Comment #114130 by Stormkahn on January 21, 2008 at 12:13 pm

 avatarSo let me get this right..... There's this guy who thinks somebody has imaginary beings in them but wants to make sure the good Doctor doesn't think their mad before he gets drive them out? Which one has the mental illness, the priest or the patient?

Keep banging the rocks together guys....

Other Comments by Stormkahn

18. Comment #114152 by BAEOZ on January 21, 2008 at 1:03 pm

 avatar
If a Christian is somebody who follows the example of Christ, these people are true and good Christians – and they are also deeply immoral human beings.

Classic quote. Baby Jesus, meek and mild, will kill you if you don't do as he says.

Other Comments by BAEOZ

19. Comment #114160 by kmorgan on January 21, 2008 at 1:15 pm

 avatarI always thought exorcisms were for backward countries and movies until a guy I work with (a self described "Charismatic" who is taking lessons from his church in tongue speaking) described exorcisms he regularly attended at a Catholic church in New Jersey. He'd invited me to come along, an invitation I passed along to the New England Skeptical Society and they promptly advised me to stay away from these people.

Very scary stuff going on. Hard to believe it's the 21st century.

Other Comments by kmorgan

20. Comment #114231 by Crazymalc on January 21, 2008 at 3:31 pm

 avatarSome of you might find this interesting. It was from one such crazy exorcism in Uganda.

http://www.crazymalc.co.nz/06Nov/08Nov/08Nov.htm

Other Comments by Crazymalc

21. Comment #114235 by alexmzk on January 21, 2008 at 3:43 pm

awful.

Other Comments by alexmzk

22. Comment #114237 by Darwin's badger on January 21, 2008 at 3:48 pm

 avatarIn years to come - hopefully sooner, rather than later - the vast majority of the world will think that 21st century people were savages. It's good to know that there are a substantial amount of us who already know that to be true of many.

Other Comments by Darwin's badger

23. Comment #114243 by Cartomancer on January 21, 2008 at 3:58 pm

 avatarI wonder what a Church of England exorcist would do - offer the demons a piece of cake and a chat, then ask nicely if maybe they could tone down the jolly unsporting behaviour or, if they could, no pressure or anything, go and find somewhere else to play, thank you so much...?

Other Comments by Cartomancer

24. Comment #114248 by bliktor on January 21, 2008 at 4:04 pm

 avatarAlthough it's years since he's seen the movie The Exorcist, he thinks it's broadly accurate, explaining, "As a Catholic, I would use those methods, yes.

Putting aside for one second how horrendous and inhuman this is, at least we found out that the exorcism performed in the in the Exorcist was on the mark...I can't even try to joke anymore about this. Fucking disgusting! Not only should that priest and girls parents be given the same treatment, but everyone in the religion that goes along with this insanity. I think a fitting end to the Nazi popes reign would be him tied up and tortured until he "confesses."

Other Comments by bliktor

25. Comment #114254 by Big City on January 21, 2008 at 4:26 pm

 avatarbabrock,
I'm pretty sure you can delete those 4 inadvertent posts.

Other Comments by Big City

26. Comment #114346 by Andrea on January 22, 2008 at 3:13 am

Darwinbulldog said:
Say what you want about this story but at least they got the devil out of her. Theres nothing more scarier then having made up imaginary demons in you.


There is.
Having imaginary demons waiting for you in the "afterlife", eager to torture you for eternity.

Other Comments by Andrea

27. Comment #114348 by Tyler Durden on January 22, 2008 at 3:16 am

 avatar
Having imaginary demons waiting for you in the "afterlife", eager to torture you for eternity.
Not to mention having your own parents tell you about these "demons" should you not behave!

Other Comments by Tyler Durden

28. Comment #114387 by GoneGolfing on January 22, 2008 at 6:15 am

Unfortunately this vile abuse will never stop as long as religion exists.

As pointed out, the fact that Jesus preformed this very ritual, automatically makes it a foundational practice that must be preformed if one is to follow the New Testament teachings to the letter..... The admission by the church that all unusual behavior by an individual is due to mental illness or chemical imbalances and not demonic possesion, would shake the church to its very core and do serious damage to the teachings of the Bible.

I love the story done by CBS and 60 minutes on a young lady 17 with Tourette's Syndrome. This is a neurological disorder which causes sudden and involuntary body movements and vocal outbursts called Tics. The young ladies parents had many Quacktard Fundies tell them that the girl was demon possesed and the parents very graciously yet wisely ignored them and searched with the help of Science for an answer. This answer was finally found when through research a small electrode was implanted into this beautiful young ladies brain to correct a faulty impulse and the girl was immediately cured of her syndrome and the Tics........No moron splashing her with fluids, punching her in the stomach or shoving a cross down her throat was required.

Its beautiful when Science exposes Religion for what it is..... manipulative, oppressive and dangerous bullshit.

GG :-)

Other Comments by GoneGolfing

29. Comment #114428 by Barbara on January 22, 2008 at 7:49 am

 avatarThere's a long way to go yet. All I can say is, thank goodness that we have the Four Horseman and others to articulate our opposition to religion and its' vile effects. The internet also helps to inform and motivate more people than ever before.

Religion must die!

Other Comments by Barbara

30. Comment #114435 by al-rawandi on January 22, 2008 at 7:57 am

 avatarExorcism has provided ample fodder for cinema. Precisely because it IS fiction.

Other Comments by al-rawandi

31. Comment #114437 by al-rawandi on January 22, 2008 at 7:57 am

 avatarAlso,


I believe American children have died during these kind of procedures.

Other Comments by al-rawandi

32. Comment #114590 by John Lee on January 22, 2008 at 12:41 pm

What have the religious apologists got to say about this??
Incidentally, are there any posts about hymns anywhere? I can still see my old headmaster bellowing out "Onward Christian Soldiers" with a terrifying gleam in his eye...

Other Comments by John Lee

33. Comment #114601 by Goldy on January 22, 2008 at 12:56 pm

I believe American children have died during these kind of procedures

As have New Zealanders - in the news recently and indeed found in this site somewhere...

Other Comments by Goldy

34. Comment #114604 by Paula Kirby on January 22, 2008 at 1:00 pm

 avatarHmmm. Where are ADH and Krisking and Wooter and Fides et Ratio when it really WOULD be interesting to hear them try to defend their god?

Other Comments by Paula Kirby

35. Comment #114612 by Sauveterre on January 22, 2008 at 1:23 pm

 avatar
"Thank God," he said, "we have a Pope who has decided to confront the devil head-on." (One representative of this evil, he added, is Harry Potter.)


Ah, yes, we must denounce the horrific evil of fictional books(funny, no?)....and then abuse our children to act in accordance with the Lord's plan.

Is it just me, or is this the most warped view on morality you have ever heard seriously, soberly proposed?

"Holy Spirit, I deny thee, in Daniel Radcliffe's name!"

Other Comments by Sauveterre

36. Comment #114621 by Goldy on January 22, 2008 at 1:31 pm

Paula, there's a few defensive letters in the Independent.

Other Comments by Goldy

37. Comment #114812 by cerbera on January 22, 2008 at 11:48 pm

heart-sinking stuff...

Other Comments by cerbera

38. Comment #114814 by Veronique on January 23, 2008 at 12:03 am

 avatarbabrock

Hit the little x at the top right hand side of your inadvertent posts to remove them.

Good luck - edit you have to be logged in to perform this.
V:-)

Other Comments by Veronique

39. Comment #114815 by Veronique on January 23, 2008 at 12:06 am

 avatar34. Comment #114604 by Paula Kirby

Hahahaha. I suspect they are all very busy with serious and portentous stuff:-). It must be difficult for them to post here when there is so much good work that they have to undertake on a immediate basis:-)

V

Other Comments by Veronique

40. Comment #114817 by BAEOZ on January 23, 2008 at 12:26 am

 avatar
Where are ADH and Krisking and Wooter and Fides et Ratio when it really WOULD be interesting to hear them try to defend their god?


Paula, you don't understand. That's not their god, nor his will. You silly sod, you don't realise that ADH, Krisking, Wooter and Fides sin ratio have a real, meaningful understanding of God and his will. Those other people are sadly following the wrong path. God and religion are not to be blamed for them, oh no. Just ask them, I'm sure they'll corroborate this. :) And aren't us atheists always asking for corroborating evidence?

Other Comments by BAEOZ

41. Comment #114827 by scottishgeologist on January 23, 2008 at 1:08 am

 avatarNote the key phrase in this whol hideous article:

"Her Pentecostalist priest"

That f****** "P" word again. And I dont mean priest. Man these people infuriate me with their

Pentecostalism is spreading like the cancer it is in the 3rd world. It seems to really catch on in nations and places where there is already a strong element of native folk religion, spiritism and all that sort of thing.

These people live in a fantasy world.

Other Comments by scottishgeologist

42. Comment #114832 by Veronique on January 23, 2008 at 1:19 am

 avatar41. Comment #114827 by scottishgeologist

Stop getting hot under the collar, SG, and making typos that you never normally make:-)

Calm down, have a cup of tea (or a wine, as I am wont to do:-), write a strongly worded letter to the Times:-). Thanks Brigstocke!!

Are you actually in Scotland?? my dear geologist? If you are I would love to meet you in August.

Let's take on the Flea! What do you say? Good fun or what?

My best
V

Other Comments by Veronique

43. Comment #114893 by GoneGolfing on January 23, 2008 at 6:15 am

Scottish G.

I can understand your feelings about this for sure. Being raised by parents who were pentecostals and being forced to attend a church of the same, I witnessed first hand what the mindset of these people are.

If your a pentecostal you've bought the full meal deal...speaking in tounges...being slain in the spirit...exorcisms...laying on of hands for healing.. etc.. etc....I don't think there's a denomination alive that takes the Bible more literal than the pentecostals.

I would say that at least 90% of the Big Guns in TV evangelism have pentecostal roots.

We have a TV evangelist here in Toronto that runs a church called the Prayer Palace. He's a white hellfire preaching in your face guy that has a congregation of 5,000 and an investigation by the Toronto Star News showed that he built this mega church in a predominately black section of Toronto and therefore it consists of 80% blue collar and low income black folks of which he's full bore pentecostal with. He himself however, lives in a multi million dollar home, drives several luxury cars and has a 4,000 sq. ft. home in Florida. He constantly preaches about money, blessings, and success, of course which the more you give of the former the more you get of the latter, and that of course is extremely appealing to any blue collar or low income person regardless of race. (And we also all know that teaching is a huge smelly pile of bullshit). The only truth that is seen of the blessing he speaks of is that its lining "his" pockets quite nicely! It's mind boggling that his flock won't wake up and see what this leech is up to!

A member of his flock responded to a Star question on giving with "" Our Pastor is worth every penny we give him! We love him so much !!""

Barf Bag Please !

GG :-)

Other Comments by GoneGolfing

44. Comment #114982 by PaulJ on January 23, 2008 at 11:21 am

 avatarCheck out this TV programme.

The Rev Bob Larson casts out demons wherever he finds them (and he finds them everywhere!)

Other Comments by PaulJ

45. Comment #114989 by scottishgeologist on January 23, 2008 at 11:35 am

 avatarGoneGolfing

Yes, "Prosperity Theology" thats the name of the game. To the extent that "Pastor Gas" (Robert Tilton) reckoned that poverty was BECAUSE of sin.

Tilton (Farting Preacher)here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpNNADzzuz8

ROFL or what???!!!

But seriously folks, there are some seriously weird people out there who believe some seriously weird stuff. Check out this guy:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCXVB4Hun44

Tilton is ridiculous. This guy is dangerous

Other Comments by scottishgeologist

46. Comment #115098 by hoops mccann on January 23, 2008 at 2:45 pm

 avatar"In practice, official Catholic exorcisms have been dramatically increasing since the mid-1970s, according to Michael W. Cuneo, ..."



In other words, since the movie came out :)

Other Comments by hoops mccann

47. Comment #115127 by hoops mccann on January 23, 2008 at 3:56 pm

 avatar"I think a fitting end to the Nazi popes reign would be him tied up and tortured until he "confesses." "



Now, now.

Seriously, I don't think Mr. Ratzinger is deserving of the title "pope" (for what it's worth). I'm starting to wonder if he's earned enough respect to be called "Mr." Anyhow, that priest in Africa should be doing time somewhere.

Other Comments by hoops mccann

48. Comment #115268 by Bigorra on January 23, 2008 at 9:10 pm

 avatar
Her Pentecostalist priest, Papa Enoch Boonga, told me with pride how he had driven the demons out. They starved Clarice for four days, whipped her and threatened to burn her, until finally she "confessed."

Then they forced her to admit to everything she had done, and performed a long exorcism ceremony. They only believed it was working when her little body began to judder and howl and curse. I ask Clarice quietly if she really believed she had done all these things. "Yes," she said. "I do."


After four days of starvation, whipping and threats, almost anybody would "confess" to having been responsible for the unfortunate things that have happened to members of her family. What makes me curious is the belief that "threats to burn her" would have any effect on her if she was possessed of a demon. Presuming that the demon would have been from the Lake of Fire (ooh, scary!) it would be more logical if threats of burning would be like inviting it to stay, maybe have a cup of tea (boiling hot, please). Hurting the child's physical body shouldn't be a threat to the demon, it should be able to just mosey on over to the nearest lost soul (keep your eyes open fellow atheists) and set up shop there.

Papa Enoch Boonga and Pope Benedict's reasons for exorcism are horrid excuses for subjugation of innocent minds and an advocation of torture, although "the official Catholic exorcism rites do not involve the physical torture inflicted on Clarice." Exorcism is clearly mental abuse even when performed by a Catholic priest. Meanwhile, Pope Benedict condemns torture while saying at the same time his view are not a criticism of any particular government. Right.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2005-12-13-pope_x.htm

Other Comments by Bigorra

49. Comment #116191 by justin willemse on January 25, 2008 at 7:16 pm

sick! sick! sick!

I grew up Catholic and I have a mother that has schizophrenia. Growing up and raising a mentally ill mother on my own was a fuck of a lot of work when her friends and the local priest all believed that God was talking to her. Nothing like have a fish knife to your throat or a gun pointed to you when she was in a full delusional crisis…. When you are young, all you can do is try to get her to the hospital and hope for better medication.

The Catholic Church should have no right what so ever and dealing with mental illness.

Fuck we need to get out of this barbaric society.

It really makes me upset to hear shit like this!!!

Other Comments by justin willemse

50. Comment #128924 by mas144 on February 18, 2008 at 10:01 am

This is a VERY poor written article. Horrible actually. In case you didn't notice the whipping, cruelty, and torture was not committed by the Catholic Church. Once again the church has been blamed for something it did not due. Exorcism is very rare within the church, probably less than 500 hundred priests out of 1m clergy, out of 1 billion catholics. Furthermore, exorcism is only a last resort and is done only after all modern medical procedures do not work. (contrary to what is presented above). There is suppose to be a doctor present, and other regulations are implemented. Are these regulations sometimes abused in third world countries? Yes! But so is everything else! The church is one of the only institutions currently helping everyone in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. You see the USA lowering its interest rates to garner to big businesses, Britain currently passing appeasement laws for every right imaginable, but how much help does the secular world really give to their fellow man?

Other Comments by mas144
Reload Comments | Back to Top

More Comments: 1 2 | Next | Last

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password:

Send a letter to the editor of the original media outlet.
j.hari@ independent.co.uk