Skip to Main Content (access key 1)
Skip to Search (access key 2)
Skip to Search GO (access key 3)
Skip to comments (access key 4)
Skip to navigation (access key 5)
Skip to top of page (access key 6)
Saturday, February 3, 2007 | Science : Teaching Science | print version Print | Comments

Document The Chronicles of Kearnya, or, Principles of Evolution Observed in the Field at Kearny High School

by The Opinion Mill

Reposted from:
http://theopinionmill.wordpress.com/2007/02/02/the-chronicles-of-kearnya-or-principles-of-evolution-observed-in-the-field-at-kearny-high-school/

It will no doubt pain him to hear this, but the ongoing saga of David Paszkiewicz — the Kearny High School teacher who got caught using his classroom as a pulpit for Christianist wingnuttery — has been an object lesson in the workings of evolution, in terms of the Kearny school board's response.

Like evolution, the school board worked very slowly. Presented with a fall incident in which Paszkiewicz (whose official designation is that of a history teacher) denounced evolution as "unscientific" and told a Muslim girl she was bound for hell unless she got down with the Christianist program, the board waited until January to take any kind of action.

Like any organism caught up in the endless competition of life that powers evolutionary processes, the board also adopted a number of survival strategies.

In an attempt to placate parents and taxpayers who expect schools to be places of education instead of asylums for half-baked preachers, the board announced that it had taken some kind of unspecified disciplinary action against the Preachin' Teach. Biologists will recognize this as a "threat display," an attempt to appear big and menacing that's employed by all manner of life forms both vertebrate and (appropriately, in this case) invertebrate. Since the Preachin' Teach has reportedly been running around telling students that people who talk about global warming are using Nazi-style propaganda techniques, it seems doubtful that the threat display is very convincing.

The board also announced that all teachers would receive mandatory training on the Constitution's separation of church and state and how it should guide classroom discussions. As any marine biologist will tell you, most species of octopus and squid, when confronted with something big and scary (like representatives of the civilized world) will produce a big splurtch of ink that hangs in the water and distracts the predator while they look for a safe place to hide. Since the young man who exposed the Preachin' Teach to daylight has a father who is not inclined to take this kind of nonsense lying down, it remains to be seen if this distraction strategy will be effective.

Finally, biologists are also aware that there are life forms once capable of sight that have turned their backs on the daylight and elected instead to live in lightless caverns and stagnant pools far beneath the ground. Though some of these creatures retain vestigial traces of eyes and other sensory organs, these have become useless over the generations. These creatures paddle in darkness, untroubled by the doings of the world above.

It would appear the school board is working toward this goal by announcing that from now on, no student is permitted to tape-record a teacher during class. Since it was a tape-recording that permitted the intrepid student to expose the Preachin' Teach with evidence in the first place, we can only assume the school board would rather paddle around in the dark, signing off on maintenance reports and cafeteria menus, rather than deal head-on with the educational and intellectual malfeasance now being practiced in the school's halls.

I'm not a biologist or evolutionary theorist, simply a layman who respects both science and the bedrock principles of American society. I know there is fossil evidence of land animals returning to the sea, but I don't know if any evidence has been found of vertebrates evolving back into invertebrates.

But I think we should all keep our eyes on the Kearny school district, where such an evolutionary retreat may yet happen. It's already pretty hard to find any evidence of backbones on the school board.

For more on this story, see:
http://richarddawkins.net/article,335,Public-school-teacher-tells-class-You-belong-in-hell,Jim-Lippard

http://richarddawkins.net/article,440,Talk-in-Class-Turns-to-God-Setting-Off-Public-Debate-on-Rights,Tina-Kelley

Comments 1 - 15 of 15 |

Reload Comments | Back to Top | Page Numbers

1. Comment #20512 by Grandt on February 3, 2007 at 3:13 pm

This is a disgrace. When do people learn that sticking the head into the sand is the least effective solution to any problem ?

Other Comments by Grandt

2. Comment #20518 by MelM on February 3, 2007 at 4:22 pm

How much "getting away with it" is going on?
It would be very interesting to know just how much preaching is being done in the U.S. public schools and hasn't been caught or where the "school board would rather paddle around in the dark." If this guy didn't get fired for his outrageous behavior, then he really wasn't taking much of a risk. If schools boards elsewhere act this way, then wingnuts can use the classroom to preach without fear of serious repercussions. Anyway, I wonder in how many places teachers are "getting away with" religious and anit-evolution prattle.

Other Comments by MelM

3. Comment #20520 by Caveman on February 3, 2007 at 4:36 pm

Its not lack of backbone. The schoolboard agrees with "preachin'" in the school. That's why they are banning tape recorders. Fairly sickening since some students may wish to record the lectures merely to review them later. Of course, the content of most science instruction in high school is so poor anyway, I can't imagine why they would. I hope someone opposes the ban on recorders for that reason.

Other Comments by Caveman

4. Comment #20535 by kmccardle on February 3, 2007 at 10:01 pm

It's a good thing that the school board doesn't set the laws. Students can still record their teachers if they feel their rights are being violated and there's nothing the school board can do about it if the teacher turns out to have done something illegal/wrong/etc. I'm not even sure if the school board really has the authority to ban tape recordings anyways, but on that I'm not sure.

Other Comments by kmccardle

5. Comment #20542 by Stewart on February 4, 2007 at 12:43 am

Aha, so if we can't legalise a crime, we can at least criminalise methods of detecting crime. That's what it boils down to. Next time Paszkiewicz does it, absolutely nothing happens to him, because it can't be proved.

Other Comments by Stewart

6. Comment #20543 by seals on February 4, 2007 at 1:00 am

 avatarMaybe this is silly, but could they use their mobile phones to record, no tapes involved.

Other Comments by seals

7. Comment #20547 by Logicel on February 4, 2007 at 3:18 am

 avatarThe Kearny's forum at their website during December displayed shocking backwardness in the comments registered against this American citizen who happens to be a high school teenager--a backwardness heavy with apathy and viciousness. The dual themes were of 'oh why must we go through this trivial case again, I am so tired of this discussion, we have discussed it enough, so let's stop' and/or 'the teenager in question is a fag and anyone who supports him is one also.'

Kearny's school board action of not allowing students to record their teachers is ridiculous--university students do it all the time.

Unfortunately, the mindlesss people who live in Kearny and attend the high school in question won't do the correct action which is for every single student in that pathetic place tape record each and every teacher.

Other Comments by Logicel

8. Comment #20548 by Logicel on February 4, 2007 at 3:25 am

 avatarThe mayor of NYC took the power away from NYC's school boards and in the process improved the schools. Keep up the nonsense, New Jersey School Boards, and your schools will deteriorate to the point that you will lose control over your schools.

Other Comments by Logicel

9. Comment #20554 by Pi Guy on February 4, 2007 at 5:09 am

Here's a novel idea: record ALL classroom lectures! - You want to know if a teacher is being effective, get it on tape.
- You want to convince a parent that a student is lazy or unruly ("Not my little Johny. He helps old ladies cross the street and take abandoned kitties to the shelter!"), get it on tape.
- You want know if a History teacher is a wackjob creationist contributing to the emotional beatdown of minority students, get it on tape.

Other Comments by Pi Guy

10. Comment #20563 by vdubmatt on February 4, 2007 at 8:05 am

Hello all. I am from a NJ town nearby Kearny and want you all to know I find this teachers actions deplorable.
One note to add on the discussion of recording lectures. Almost every class I have taken in college has said that you must inform the professor that you intend to record his lectures. I do not know if there are any laws regarding this.
Another thing is that alot of people do not realize the kinds of rules that school boards impose that have absolutely no legal backing.
I will soon be an earth science teacher in NJ and it is honestly despicable what is happening here.
As a side note for thoseof you who do not know. Kearny has a notoriously high Irish Catholic. I would estimate it at something like 70 percent. This may give a clue to the reaction of local citizens and staff.

Other Comments by vdubmatt

11. Comment #20565 by John P on February 4, 2007 at 8:24 am

 avatarI don't know about the other 49 states, but in PA, it would be illegal to tape record anyone surreptitiously, without their clear consent. It's a violation of the Wiretap Law (of all things) here. It may also be in Maryland, because I vaguely remember some discussion about it during the Monica Lewinsky/Linda Tripp tape recording matter.

Other Comments by John P

12. Comment #20569 by Luthien on February 4, 2007 at 10:54 am

 avatarIn the UK it would be illegal to stop students from taping a teacher. This is to allow students that have a disability, who may be too slow at taking notes / unable to take notes, to record the teaching for later study.

Other Comments by Luthien

13. Comment #20584 by a-teapot-ist on February 4, 2007 at 3:05 pm

I fail to understand the mentality, here, because if my tax dollars are being used to pay the teachers and maintenance of these schools, then I think it'd be best on everybody's behalf if both video and audio surveillance was allowed. We'd know what the teachers would be doing, and no Salem mob controversy inspired by malicious students would occur.

Other Comments by a-teapot-ist

14. Comment #20595 by kurzweilfreak on February 4, 2007 at 7:51 pm

John P,

Are you sure that wiretap law applies to all citizens and not just members of the government and law enforcement? Usually, laws like that are provided to help protect your right to privacy in your own home and phone communications. I don't believe students taping their teachers in classrooms would fall under that heading. I could be wrong, but I would hope not.

Other Comments by kurzweilfreak

15. Comment #20641 by samuel on February 5, 2007 at 10:57 am

Complete nonsense, if anything classroom lectures should be recorded and the material made available. I would appreciate the ability to retrieve some of the wonderful lectures that were done by at least two of my HS teachers. And now they are dis-allowing the recordings? audio recordings? That may actually push the needle on the bs meter past %100. What would we do then? Ban doodling in the notebooks?

Other Comments by samuel
Reload Comments | Back to Top

Comment Entry: Please Login

Register a new account

Username:

Password:

This article is reposted from a website that accepts comments.
Why not share your comment on the article there as well? CLICK HERE