“I never, ever in my entire life had seen a Bible labeled as fiction,” Kaltenbach told ABCNews.com. “I just took the picture. I think really what has been revealed is a larger conversation over faith. There are people who are passionate about their faith in Christ and passionate against it.”

Costco said in a statement to ABCNews.com that a “small percentage of the Bibles” were mislabeled by the distributor.