










1051. Fleabytes
Comment #143447 by epeeist on March 14, 2008 at 5:50 am
Comment #143443 by Steve Zara
Shush, wooter may be listening.
"Gods make weather, and it is not a scientific question" [gone]
"Gods move the sun and moon, and it is not a scientific question" [gone]
"God made all species, and it is not a scientific question" [gone]
"God made the universe, and it is not a scientific question" ....
1052. Fleabytes
Comment #143427 by epeeist on March 14, 2008 at 5:33 am
Comment #143420 by Sargeist
It isn't very much different from what the pro-choice people want - http://www.prochoiceamerica.org/issues/
Well, when I can get around to thinking about it carefully, my opinion about abortion tends to be that I would prefer the world to be a place in which it was not necessary, but given that it is, I think that it ought to be made as simple as possible as early as possible to those who want it.
Secondly as science clearly demonstrates, it is not just your body. There is the body of the child within. Science now tells us that the body within the womb has everything that the body outwith the womb has. Why do you regard the body of the mother as sacred but the body of the child is dispensible? From a rational point of view (never mind the 'good book') it does not make sense.
1053. Fleabytes
Comment #143409 by epeeist on March 14, 2008 at 5:15 am
Comment #143397 by fides_et_ratio
How about a nice coffee shop in London?Blasphemer!
1054. Two More Fleas
Comment #143318 by epeeist on March 14, 2008 at 2:04 am
Comment #143282 by clearmind
In other words, he just did it. No explanation. I will keep this on the list of questions you haven't answered.
(1.How did god make our sense of smell?)
God created all creation with his ultimate knowledge and wisdom that is reflected on His art.
1.(How did god make the chemical receptors in your nose?)Where? Jon and I wanted the exact process, you haven't provided this. I will keep this one on the list.
(I have given you a basic outline of the biological/physical/chemical processes going on)
Does not address the question and also uses a circular argument. So far your score is 0 out of 3.
2.(What exact force do you think god used to shape our DNA? Did he use electromagnetism, gravity, weak nuclear force, or strong nuclear force? What was the mechanism used to generate this force?)
Answer:
The genetic code in the DNA proves that life on earth originated from intelligence, since information requires an intelligent sender.
1055. Fleabytes
Comment #143188 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:22 pm
Comment #143165 by Quetzalcoatl
There will apparently be a Q&A session. If anyone can think of any good questions, feel free to PM them to me, and I will try and ask some of them.
1056. Bishop accuses gays of 'conspiracy' against the Catholic Church
Comment #143045 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 11:43 am
Just dropped a line on the article comments suggesting that the Church ought to excommunicate any Catholic either being involved in or denying the Holocaust, even if they have to do it posthumously.
1057. Ban anti-Catholic books in schools, says bishop
Comment #143016 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 11:09 am
What is it about the clergy from Lancaster and its environs? First we the Bishop of Carlise claiming that homosexuality caused the floods and now we have another bishop wanting to bring back the Index Librorum Prohibitorum.
Time to write to Ed Balls I think.
1058. Fleabytes
Comment #143001 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 10:28 am
Comment #142994 by annabanana
This is a bit late, but...
Comment #142968 by SharonMcT on March 13, 2008 at 9:25 am
I agree with you totally. Nothing irritates me more.
1059. Fleabytes
Comment #142982 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 9:46 am
Comment #142935 by Steve Zara
Garden view:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mistdog/2277709922/in/set-72157600382950605/
1060. Fleabytes
Comment #142933 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 8:20 am
Comment #142927 by Steve Zara
The study I have, and my employer provides me with a good desk and chair (Miller Aeron for all you back sufferers). The garden is slightly tricky since it slopes up at about one in 6 from my window until it reaches the tennis court. Essentially all I can see is a grassy bank.
This site has motivated me to finally start planning an actual study, with organised book-shelves, a good desk and a view out to the garden.
1061. Fleabytes
Comment #142922 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 7:53 am
I know it is a truism that getting atheists to agree on anything (apart from a distinct scarcity of gods) is like herding cats. However, there is a distinct community of friends here.
I think the major thing that this site has done for me is to get me out of the eat, work, sleep cycle. It has stretched mental muscles that haven't been exercised for too long. The complaints I have is there isn't enough time in the day to stretch these muscles as much as I would like, that the equipment needed for the exercises is either in boxes (I keep raiding them and coming up with "The Scarlet Pimpernel" or "The Once and Future King" rather than "Objective Knowledge, though I did find Frege's "Theory of Judgement" the other day) that we haven't opened since we moved or has to be waited for since there is always too much month at the end of the money.
1062. Fleabytes
Comment #142905 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 7:28 am
Comment #142903 by AllanW
What do you all want to talk about now? :)We could talk about Diacanu - he has obviously gone to bed and is missing the party.
1063. Two More Fleas
Comment #142897 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 7:24 am
Comment #142890 by clearmind
Actually no, it is your turn to answer questions not to ask them. Please answer the questions here - http://richarddawkins.net/articleComments,2352,Two-More-Fleas,RichardDawkinsnet,page2#142666
Reverend, you seem to be very relaxed, while you are at it, would you please explain us how did flea mutate or evolve from what and ended with what? So much about fleas but we never talk about their spot in the evolution tree?
1064. Two More Fleas
Comment #142889 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 7:21 am
Comment #142868 by nalfeshnee
The one that I like to point out is that the only place that human crab lice can live is in human hair, particularly that around the genitals.
I like that one and will be keeping it to bring out when confronted with a similar "question".
1065. The Salamander's Tale
Comment #142854 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 6:31 am
Comment #142703 by Jon_Sociologist
You will now note that he has switched threadsWhere?
1066. Fleabytes
Comment #142835 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 6:10 am
Comment #142825 by MPhil
No, "After Virtue" stems from the early 80's, I wonder if he changed before or after he wrote it.
concerning one of your posts on page 99 - are you aware that McIntyre turned Catholic Thomist in the 80s?
On the list, like Steve Z. I think I am going to have to have a moan at what this site is costing me in books. But then - think of the value.
Also - do you know T.M. Scanlon's "What we owe to each other"? It's a Rawls-ian contractualist approach to morality... and very nice.
Indeed, its back to those lemmata again.
But not only do they need to show that the can provide a 'better' theory than Aristotle or McIntyre (before he turned nuts), they would need to show show that there are objective moral values and that there are real alternatives to consequentialism.
1067. Fleabytes
Comment #142809 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 5:45 am
The sky is falling, the sky is falling!
On a second glance - everything seems to be OK (except possibly for those Internet Exploder users).
As you were.
1068. Fleabytes
Comment #142804 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 5:39 am
Comment #142801 by clodhopper
I have every confidence that Paula has 5K ready. It just needs poof reading.I am trying to decide whether this was deliberate or not, especially given the direction of the thread over the last few posts.
1069. Fleabytes
Comment #142800 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 5:37 am
Comment #142776 by Incredulous
Hmm, my two daughters reacted in the same way (ugh, gross) if they saw my wife and I holding hands, especially in the presence of their school friends (you're embarrassing us, we'll never live it down).
I'm not quite like that, epeeist. I have gay friends, but will walk away if I see them get affectionate in a lovey dovey way towards each other. I'd rather they kept that hidden from me.
1070. Two More Fleas
Comment #142765 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 4:55 am
Comment #142681 by Steve Zara
Hmm, yes. I believe I have seen a HTML/CSS menuing system that uses the common name for these as part of its name.
In fact, "flea" is perhaps not the best term. "Remora" may be better. It is a kind of fish that rides on others.
1071. Fleabytes
Comment #142758 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 4:51 am
Comment #142743 by Steve Zara
I would even go further, as private beliefs can have public effects. I would like to see even the purely personal beliefs of, say, racists and homophobes challenged.
1072. Fleabytes
Comment #142736 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 4:09 am
For me the whole thing is fairly dull. I really don't care what theists believe. The only things I really want to do is to remove the automatic deference that they receive and their pontificating without being challenged.
The whole evidence thing only comes into play when they wish to claim, for example, primacy in moral affairs. In which case they need to show why their views are any better than those who take their ethics from Aristotle, Spinoza or McIntyre.
Similarly in matters of education or other public policies.
What consenting adults do or believe in private is none of my concern. "If everybody minded there own business the world would go around faster."
1073. Fleabytes
Comment #142719 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:44 am
Comment #142716 by ForestMist
epeeist - damn, is coffee a heresy? What is not even liking tea, let alone drinking it then?!I believe Quetz has said that he approves of all hot drinks, but tea in particular. So it may be a minor heresy. Cartomancer has obviously been punished for drinking so many cold drinks.
1074. Fleabytes
Comment #142710 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:30 am
Comment #142704 by Diacanu
Strip the bullshit out of christianity, and you may as well have deism or Buddhism.Oh, you know I had never even thought of that ;-)
1075. Fleabytes
Comment #142709 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:27 am
Comment #142702 by ForestMist
LorienRyan - I'm just being grumpy because I don't have any Lindor's here :(I am indulging in various heresies here - coffee (rather than tea) and Green and Black's 70% Chocolate Coated Butter Biscuits With Ginger (rather than Lindor's).
1076. Fleabytes
Comment #142705 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:23 am
Comment #142701 by Steve Zara
Soon she will be reaching page 100. Isn't it traditional to get a letter or telegram from a queen on reaching 100? I'll do the honours if required..
1077. The Salamander's Tale
Comment #142692 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 3:04 am
Comment #142688 by Jon_Sociologist
You will now note that he has switched threads. I suspect we may not see him back here.
Comment #142091 by clearmind:
1078. Fleabytes
Comment #142685 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 2:44 am
Comment #142671 by ForestMist
I know I am more of a "lurker" than a poster, but I have to say that I don't see a problem with asking a theist for evidence to prove what they are saying.Personally I would be more impressed if the theists started applying some kind of evidential testing by themselves.
1079. Two More Fleas
Comment #142676 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 2:17 am
Comment #142670 by clearthinker
Its an interesting question. Why did you have to undermine it with that last sentence?
I understand that. But is it really the case that all the atheist books currently being published have nothing to do with the success of TGD?
[snip]
Its good to see RD.net keeping up its usual standards!
1080. Two More Fleas
Comment #142666 by epeeist on March 13, 2008 at 1:33 am
Comment #142592 by clearmind
Okay let's prove that "Has anyone provided a proof of God's existence?" is proved.
None of these have you answered. We tried to reduce it further to:
- How did god make our sense of smell?
- How did god make us able to feel emotion? I want the exact method.
- How did god make the chemical receptors in your nose? What evidence can you present to support any answer given? I have given you a basic outline of the biological/physical/chemical processes going on, please do the same.
- What exact force do you think god used to shape our DNA? Did he use electromagnetism, gravity, weak nuclear force, or strong nuclear force? What was the mechanism used to generate this force?
- Did he use something akin to an electron microscope to move things around? Did he use incredibly tiny tweezers?
- Seeing as he's a he: what does an omnipotent immortal god need a penis for?
- What goddess is he poking with it if he's the only deity?
- What happened to the other gods in the old testament that apparently once existed but don't now (Baal for example)
1081. Fleabytes
Comment #142415 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 12:57 pm
Comment #142394 by al-rawandi
I have done consultancy in a variety of countries, including both Germany and the USA. Small sample of course and nothing to do with the French.
As for the French. They have problems getting anything done with bloated unions and a 35 hour work week (the average American works 50 hours per week). The French (and most of Europe) benefit from the strong American economy.
1082. Beauty ad banned after Christian outcry
Comment #142391 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 12:40 pm
Comment #142386 by Gustaf Sjoblom
So what you are saying is that the use of the cross is crass.
The sole reason for this would be the t turned into a cross. It directly references a specific religion. If they simply changed it to a normal t I see no trouble with the ad.
1083. Fleabytes
Comment #142389 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 12:37 pm
Comment #142380 by al-rawandi
MPhil has it about right I think.
Well let's be honest here. WWII was IN France, not Ohio. So by that fact alone there is a strong bias in terms of numbers.
1084. Beauty ad banned after Christian outcry
Comment #142377 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 12:16 pm
Comment #142369 by DavidJGrossman
Step 1: Create controversial ad
Step 2: Wait for cries of persecution from xians
Step 3: Free publicity!
1085. Fleabytes
Comment #142373 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 12:12 pm
Comment #142353 by al-rawandi
Compare how many people they lost in WWII (both civilian and military) as a percentage of the population compared to those lost by the USA. Get the figures for Europe as well as the global figures. Wikipedia is your friend.
They have a whiny troll (Sarkozy) for president. They have masterfully surrendered in several major conflicts.
1086. The Salamander's Tale
Comment #142302 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 9:30 am
Comment #142290 by Geoff
Wooter, the difference between evolution and abiogenesis has been explained to you several hundred times.
1087. Fleabytes
Comment #142276 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 8:47 am
Comment #141711 by Richard Morgan
Outside of writing dots on lines I'm not very imaginative, I'm afraid.
1088. Fleabytes
Comment #142232 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 7:07 am
Comment #142228 by al-rawandi
You aren't intimating some kind of personal causation for teenage pregnancies and STDs on behalf of your president are you?
Since Bush's "Abstinence Only" has been played out, teen pregnancy is through the roof, and 1 in 4 teen girls has an STD. Thanks for that George. I am wondering if there is anything he won't fuck up.
1089. Fleabytes
Comment #142216 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 6:48 am
Comment #142204 by mlearnedfriend
You aren't going to get this. What you will get is that some elements will have a high degree of verisimilitude since there will be corroborative independent evidence. Other parts will be false, since it will be counter-factual and then there will be material for which, at best, you may be able to assign some kind of fuzzy probability. Assigning truth or falsity to the whole bible isn't going to be possible.
Also, could you tell me the ten (or five) archaeological discoveries that show the Biblical record to be demonstrably false. That'll give me something to work on.
1090. Fleabytes
Comment #142178 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 5:57 am
Comment #142164 by The Reverend Dark
Once you toss the requirement for evidence to the side you are leaving yourself open to all manner of arse-wipery, from god to fairies, to invisible garage dragons to Bert the Magic Sodding Penguin.
1091. The Salamander's Tale
Comment #142151 by epeeist on March 12, 2008 at 4:39 am
Comment #142144 by Mitchell Gilks
I would suggest that you guys just stop feeding the trolls. Just like cancer, if you ignore it, it will go away...that works right?
1092. Fleabytes
Comment #142011 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 3:18 pm
Comment #142008 by robotaholic
I have an apointment with the doctor next week to get antabuse. I am quitting drinking forever hopefully soonWell you have all my best wishes.
1093. Fleabytes
Comment #142009 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 3:13 pm
Comment #142002 by al-rawandi
Got to agree with Richard Morgan - it really isn't that easy.
The best way to quit drinking....
Put the bottle down.
1094. Seven new deadly sins: are you guilty?
Comment #141911 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 11:28 am
Comment #141908 by lostpoet
He's already been, didn't you know? However, he supposedly got out again by his own efforts. However, you have to wonder...
But wait again, "...punishing children for the iniquity of parents...? Pretty clear example of "social injustice!" So it looks like God is going to hell after all.
1095. Seven new deadly sins: are you guilty?
Comment #141901 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 10:55 am
Comment #141897 by irate_atheist
I must call God a prick more often.
1096. Fleabytes
Comment #141900 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 10:53 am
Comment #141898 by MPhil
I come across this very often... they simply say something to the effect of ''God' has nothing to do with evidence' or 'God cannot be known, his presence can only be felt'...
1097. Fleabytes
Comment #141876 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 10:07 am
Comment #141848 by Incredulous
At its best, yes. Unfortunately we seem to have reverted it being the ability to pass exams and then having sufficient training to fill a job role.
Surely, western education is a childhood long exercise in the type of thinking which emphasises facts, observation, logical and critical thinking.
1098. Fleabytes
Comment #141870 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 10:01 am
Comment #141852 by hungarianelephant
Have a glance at wikipedia for coherence and correspondence theories of truth. I suspect this might cover what your are getting at.
See, apart from the compartmentalisation problem which kaiserkriss refers to, I think the problem here is with the word "truth".
When scientists use the word, they mean "factually correct".
1099. Fleabytes
Comment #141828 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 9:14 am
Comment #141821 by Incredulous
Are we in danger of intellectualising atheism and therefore turning it into a mere tool for sharpening the wits of the well educated?
1100. Fleabytes
Comment #141823 by epeeist on March 11, 2008 at 9:00 am
Comment #141815 by fides_et_ratio
Could I say that as the nephew of someone who died from alcoholism and the brother of someone else who died from the same affliction I don't find that particularly helpful.
It's irrational for a recovering alcoholic not to pray.