A toxic legacy


Illegal dumping of toxic waste in the Italian Campania has been blamed for high rates of ill health in the region. The suspected link needs to be investigated using the most modern methods.

It is tempting to see health hazards everywhere, especially if one believes the tabloid press. From the air we breathe to the food we eat and the fun we have, the risks of normal, everyday life have never received more attention.

But the people who live in the fertile agricultural landscape of Italy’s Campania region, around the historic city of Naples, have genuine reason to be anxious about their health. For decades they have lived on top ofpotentially lethal toxic waste, illegally and secretly dumped there by the mafia. Rates of some cancers are higher, and lifespans shorter, than elsewhere in Italy. Complaints, though, have been continually silenced.

But Italian environmental police, working closely with anti-mafia forces, have used smart technologies to discover the subterranean dumps and are now systematically excavating them. Environmental officials are analysing soil and water. The crater walls look like geological strata, each layer formed by different types of waste: asbestos from demolished buildings, dioxin-rich chemical sludge, drums of solvent, the odd motor vehicle. Black water forms pools at the bottom. No one is allowed to even look into the stinking, steaming pits without a respirator mask.

Massive street demonstrations in Naples last autumn prompted officials to take action. The national government approved funding earlier this year for a two-year programme in which the several hundred thousand people who live close to the dumps will be screened for cancers that have been linked to environmental exposure. The health ministry has analysed all the health and environment studies carried out so far and concluded that there is no evidence yet to link the dumps to cancer. Yet local people are convinced that noxious run-off from the dumps is gradually killing them and their families, loading their bodies with toxic chemicals and twisting their cells into tumours. They want answers, and they want the scientists to supply them.

Toxic black box

Environmental police have so far identified 32 sites containing an estimated minimum of 3.5 million cubic metres of toxic waste. But without crucial information about actual exposure, including dose levels, it is impossible to determine whether the dumped chemicals have raised cancer risk in what is a poor region, where people smoke more and have unhealthier lifestyles than in other parts of the country.

Similar issues arise whenever cancer clusters emerge around nuclear power plants or industrial sites. Attempts to prove a causal link face several dilemmas. One is that the number of cancer cases is usually too small for conclusive statistics. Another is that the cancers usually become apparent years after the hypothetical exposure to carcinogen, and such historical exposures are almost impossible to prove scientifically. But usually, the identity of the feared chemicals is known.

In Campania, the challenge is greater because the very fundamentals are unknown — not only the location and chemical content of the dumps, but also the true local incidence of cancer. Over the past year or so, that information has started to emerge. And biologists there are wondering if they might be able to tie their whole noxious experience into the global research effort to develop methods to prove chemical exposure scientifically. Could their poisoned fields serve as a giant experiment in the new science of ‘exposomics’, which aims to identify biomarkers of past and present exposure to toxic environmental chemicals?

Written By: Nature
continue to source article at nature.com


  1. Shocking….It makes you wonder where all the waste has gone in every country before the days of crackdowns and standards, companies would be paid top bucks to remove toxic waste….but no one checked where to ?

  2. In reply to #1 by Light Wave:

    Shocking….It makes you wonder where all the waste has gone in every country before the days of crackdowns and standards, companies would be paid top bucks to remove toxic waste….but no one checked where to ?

    If you ask the mafia to dispose of something you never ask them where. Capish!

    I think this problem is specific to having a mafia controlled waste disposal system. Not a problem for most countries nor was this a problem from before standards.

Leave a Reply