The Persecution of Witches, 21st-Century Style

Jul 11, 2014

By Mitch Horowitz

Most people believe that the persecution of “witches” reached its height in the early 1690s with the trials in Salem, Mass., but it is a grim paradox of 21st-century life that violence against people accused of sorcery is very much still with us. Far from fading away, thanks to digital interconnectedness and economic development, witch hunting has become a growing, global problem.

In recent years, there has been a spate of attacks against people accused of witchcraft in Africa, the Pacific and Latin America, and even among immigrant communities in the United States and Western Europe. Researchers with United Nations refugee and human rights agencies have estimated the murders of supposed witches as numbering in the thousands each year, while beatings and banishments could run into the millions. “This is becoming an international problem — it is a form of persecution and violence that is spreading around the globe,” Jeff Crisp, an official with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, told a panel in 2009, the last year in which an international body studied the full dimensions of the problem. A report that year from the same agency and a Unicef study in 2010 both found a rise, especially in Africa, of violence and child abuse linked to witchcraft accusations.

More recent media reports suggest a disturbing pattern of mutilation and murder. Last year, a mob in Papua New Guinea burned alive a young mother, Kepari Leniata, 20, who was suspected of sorcery. This highly publicized case followed a series of instances over recent years of lethal group violence against women and men accused of witchcraft.

“These are becoming all too common in certain parts of the country,” said the prime minister, Peter O’Neill. Last year, Papua New Guinea finally repealed a 1971 law that permitted attackers to cite intent to combat witchcraft as a legal defense. But progress is slow. Although the police charged a man and woman in connection with the 2013 killing of Ms. Leniata, no one has faced trial, a fact that drew protest from Amnesty International in February.

One of the ugliest aspects of these crimes is their brutality. Victims are often burned alive, as in Ms. Leniata’s case and a 2012 case in Nepal; or accused women are sometimes beaten to death, as occurred in the Colombian town of Santa Barbara in 2012; or the victims may be stoned or beheaded, as has been reported in Indonesia and sub-Saharan Africa.

It is tempting to point to poverty in the developing world, as well as scapegoating, as the chief causes of anti-witch attacks — and such forces are undoubtedly at work. But while Africa and the southwestern Pacific have a long history of economic misery, much of this violence, especially against children, has worsened since 2000. The surge suggests forces other than economic resentment or ancient superstition.

In some communities, it is chiefly young men who take on the role of witch hunters, suggesting that they may see it as a way to earn prestige by cleansing undesirables and enforcing social mores. That many of the self-appointed witch hunters are men highlights another baleful aspect of the phenomenon: The majority of victims are women. The Rev. Jack Urame of the Melanesian Institute, a Papua New Guinean human rights agency, estimates that witchcraft-related violence there is directed 5 to 1 against women, suggesting that witchcraft accusations are used to cloak gender-based violence.

Another factor, particularly in Central Africa and its diaspora communities, is the advent of revivalist churches, in which self-styled pastor-prophets rail against witchery and demon possession. They often claim to specialize in the casting out of evil spirits, sometimes charging for the service. Many of those congregations have emerged from Western evangelizing efforts.

One of Nigeria’s most popular Pentecostal preachers, Helen Ukpabio, wrote that “if a child under the age of 2 screams in the night, cries and is always feverish with deteriorating health, he or she is a servant of Satan.” As that implies, children in those communities are especially likely to be identified as possessed. The United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights reported that most of the 25,000 to 50,000 children who live on the streets of Kinshasa, the capital of the Democratic Republic of Congo, were abandoned by family members who accused them of witchcraft or demonic possession.

The etiology of this epidemic is complex, but human rights observers point to overpopulation, rapid urbanization and the hardship of parents forced to relocate to seek work, as well as the sheer stresses of raising children amid dire poverty. Superstitions are stoked by local “healers,” who charge parents to exorcise evil spirits.

Witch hunting is far from limited, however, to acts of sadistic vigilantism or profiteering. Some legal systems even sanction the killing of accused witches.

In 2011, courts in Saudi Arabia sentenced a man and a woman, in separate cases, to beheading after convictions for sorcery. In 2013, Saudi courts sentenced two Asian housemaids to 1,000 lashes and 10 years in prison on charges of casting spells against their employers.

A Lebanese television psychic, Ali Hussain Sibat, was arrested in 2008, while on pilgrimage to Medina, by the Saudi religious police for hosting a television show in his native Lebanon, “The Hidden,” where he would make predictions and prescribe love potions and spells. After an outcry by Amnesty International and others, the Saudi courts stayed Mr. Sibat’s execution by beheading, but sentenced him in 2010 to a 15-year prison term.

9 comments on “The Persecution of Witches, 21st-Century Style

  • The etiology of this epidemic is complex, but human rights observers point to overpopulation, rapid urbanization and the hardship of parents forced to relocate to seek work, as well as the sheer stresses of raising children amid dire poverty.

    One of the best ways to tackle the first would be legally mandated educational standards for sex and family planning, and another would be a one-child policy like the one in China. I’m not sure why rapid urbanisation would be a problem by itself, but I hardly think it ethical to deny people in these regions a chance to at least reach First World levels of comfort, for equality’s sake. Employment related issues depend upon a strengthened economy, and ideally a sustainable one that still maintains traditional cultural trappings (the ones worth preserving, at least).

    I don’t know how employment-driven immigration is necessarily involved, either, nor why it is any more difficult than, say, US citizens moving to different states for work reasons, so I’d like to see someone else’s take on this. Lastly, dire poverty would be alleviated by a stronger economy and political structure, too, though achieving either would be nowhere near as easy as I make it sound.

    I feel a bit uneasy about suggesting that superstition doesn’t play that big a role in it, though. If it were just a matter of economic frustration, you’d expect violence to be random and senseless, simply cathartic and explicitly competitive, like how certain animals (social ones, like rats) lash out at any fellow creature nearby when pressured in order to claim some breathing space.

    Yet there’s a clear, directed rationale for this violence. That is this: “We’re in hard times because that woman up the street is a servant of Satan cursing everybody, so if we kill her she’ll stop cursing us and things will improve.” That not only needs the extra, directed ingredient of superstition, but raises the question of where that superstition is coming from and why it isn’t being intercepted and challenged. Are people in the region just inventing witches out of whole cloth and then persuading others about it, or is the belief being introduced from outside, ready-formed, by others? It makes a difference because a large part of tackling the erroneous belief will involve finding out how it came about, and who to target as part of the problem.

    It needs addressing because, in addition to the already-difficult issues of economy, politics, and sustainable cultural practices such as contraception and sexual health awareness, you’re going to have to dismantle the belief in witches somehow to stop the killing. Doubly so if the belief is fuelled by emotional and moral investments, which given the context it undoubtedly is.

    Report abuse

  • The Unicef study linked to in the OP doesn’t hold back as to where they attribute a significant portion of the blame, which is really refreshingly honest compared to the frequent circumvention of the religious issue seen in these kind of reports by many supposedly impartial UN organisations:

    2.2. Predominance of Christianity

    Churches, especially those belonging to the Pentecostal and prophetic movement (charismatic, revivalist, etc.), play an important role in the diffusion and legitimization of fears related to witchcraft, and in particular, child witches. The pastor‐prophet is an important figure in the process of accusing children of witchcraft, by effectively validating the presence of a “witchcraft spirit”. Pentecostalists, for example, present their faith as a form of divine armour against witchcraft, and they participate actively in the fight against Evil that is incarnated through witchcraft.

    The fact that people of any age are still being persecuted and killed for witchcraft in this day and age is bad enough, but supposed ‘adults’ and ‘authority figures’ who persecute and harm innocent children on the basis of their own delusions have to be the worst form of morally reprehensible human beings on the Planet.

    Report abuse

  • Events such as this tempt me to put the adjective militant in front of my self-described atheism. I wish someone with the means of say a Bill Gates, would step up and make eliminating this sort of behaviour a priority. It would be advantageous to cure all the other ills of poverty and ignorance at the same time as it can be bundled together for the most part.

    It’s dreadful to witness the continuation of such tribal practices in migrant communities. I trust they’re performed by the newly arrived, but maybe not. The shameful nature of crimes like this needs to be hammered home (hopefully without demonising the community in the process).

    Report abuse

  • 4
    Miserablegit says:

    Sadly these practices are all too familiar, they involve Christianity, women are the victims, they are brutally murderded and invariably there is a ‘charismatic’ shit-stirring god botherer involved.

    Report abuse

  • I lived in Kuwait and Dubai for nearly a decade and they arrest people in both countries for witchcraft and being “devil worshippers” almost daily.

    Muslims consider any religion other than Islam or Christianity to be witchcraft so if you have any other faith ( including buddhist) don’t make it known publicly and don’t bring in any artifacts or they can arrest you at the airport.

    Anything can be considered a sorcery artifact if they really want to arrest you….. Incense……candles……..oils…..rock music.

    Report abuse

  • 7
    rodrigoallves says:

    More present than I care to admit myself. Here’s another case right in my backyard (and just a couple months ago).

    The headline goes: “Women beaten after social media rumors dies in Guaruja, São Paulo”.
    Some context, she was accused of witchcraft.

    This isn’t some remote part of the Amazon where some tribes live all but cut off from modern society; this is São Paulo, our biggest metropolitan city, the financial center of Brazil.

    Report abuse

Leave a Reply

View our comment policy.