Alan Alda’s ‘Flame Challenge’ For 2015: What is Sleep?

Dec 18, 2014

This year’s contest offers a new cash prize for scientists who can explain complex science in a way that will awaken the interest of thousands of 11-year-olds

STONY BROOK, NY, DECEMBER 2, 2014 – The Alan Alda Center for Communicating Science at Stony Brook University is challenging scientists to answer an eye-opening question:  What is sleep?

That is the wake-up call for scientists in this year’s edition of the Flame Challenge. In this international contest, scientists – from graduate students to senior researchers – are challenged to communicate complex science in ways that will interest and enlighten 11-year-olds, who judge the contest.

“I came up with this contest as a fun challenge for scientists to explain a complex thing like a flame in a way that would make it clear to an 11 year old,” said actor, writer and science advocate Alan Alda, a visiting professor at Stony Brook University.  “The idea was to urge scientists to communicate more clearly. I didn’t realize what an extraordinary learning experience it was going to be for the 11-year-olds. By now, tens of thousands of kids from all over the world have excitedly delved into the mysteries of nature as they’ve judged the scientists’ entries.

“This year’s question — “What is sleep?” — should wake them up to a whole new understanding of that third of our lives we know so little about,” said Alda. Besides kicking off the Flame Challenge, the multi-tasking Alda is currently appearing on Broadway in the play “Love Letters.”

Scientists have until Feb. 13, 2015 to submit their answers in writing, video or graphics. This year, for the first time, a $1,000 cash prize will go to the scientists who submit the two winning answers, one written entry and one video or graphic entry.  In addition, as in past years, the winning scientists will receive a trip to New York City, where they will meet Alan Alda and be honored at the World Science Festival in May, 2015. The Flame Challenge is generously sponsored by the American Chemical Society (ACS) and the AAAS.

The entries will be screened for scientific accuracy before being judged by schoolchildren around the world. Last year, 27,000 students were registered through their schools to serve as Flame Challenge judges. The Flame Challenge began in 2011 with actor and science advocate Alan Alda’s childhood query: What is a flame? Since then, the questions have been chosen from hundreds submitted by children. In 2012, scientists wrestled with “What is time?” Last year, they took on “What is color?”

“The Flame Challenge is an ingenious competition that we proudly support,” says 2015 ACS President Diane Grob Schmidt. “It challenges scientists to explain the world around us in ways that are both understandable and engaging to children. In doing so, the Flame Challenge has ignited a bonfire of interest among children worldwide. It is truly a spark that could help inspire them to explore careers in science and find ways to address the many global challenges facing all of us.”

This year’s question, “What is sleep?” was submitted by Ms. Wohlberg’s sixth grade class from Garden City Middle School in New York.   Several other students from around the country asked related questions, such as “What are dreams?” In an online poll of children about the next Flame Challenge question, “What is sleep” strongly outpolled questions about electricity, wind, germs and how scientific discoveries are made.

“This is the first Flame Challenge that asks a question about something that happens inside our brains and our bodies,” said Elizabeth Bass, director of the Alda Center. “We hope that inspires past Flame Challenge contestants to try again, and also attracts people in psychology, medicine and all the cognitive sciences. But the winners don’t necessarily have to be specialists in the topic — they mainly have to focus on understanding what 11-year-olds might know and care about.”

At the Flame Challenge website,, scientists can find more information on entering the contest, and teachers can find information on having their classes participate as judges.    The website also contains past winning entries and tips from past winners about crafting a good entry.

“The Flame Challenge is unique,” said one of last year’s winners, Melanie Golob of Olympia, WA. “It not only educates us as the scientists who answer the question, but it also gives kids the opportunity to deeply engage in a discussion on a complex scientific topic. This can be the spark that ignites a lifelong passion for science.”

Like many of the past winners, Golob is active in communicating about science to the public. Besides working for a company called Doctor Evidence, she is creating a science TV show called “Science This!” applying real science to everyday situations (or not-so-everyday situations); the website is

The annual Flame Challenge contest is part of the Alan Alda Center for Communicating Science’s mission of helping scientists communicate more effectively with the public. Located in Stony Brook University’s School of Journalism, the Alda Center gives innovative Communicating Science courses for graduate students in the sciences, and conducts workshops around the country. Alan Alda is a founding member of the Alda Center and a Visiting Professor in the School of Journalism.

The Flame Challenge’s sponsors are both major nonprofit scientific societies. The American Chemical Society is chartered by the U.S. Congress and is a global leader in providing access to chemistry-related research. ACS encourages each of its 164,000 members to speak simply about their science and its importance to all of our lives. The American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), the world’s largest multidisciplinary scientific society and publisher of the journal Science, was founded in 1848. It includes some 261 affiliated groups, serving a total of 10 million individuals, and its mission is to “advance science and serve society.”


8 comments on “Alan Alda’s ‘Flame Challenge’ For 2015: What is Sleep?

  • I have a conjecture. We are always either dreaming or unconscious. Our waking state is just a dream with some additional inputs enabled to influence the plot and our motor neurons engaged.

    Report abuse

  • “The idea was to urge scientists to communicate more clearly. I didn’t
    realize what an extraordinary learning experience it was going to be
    for the 11-year-olds. By now, tens of thousands of kids from all over
    the world have excitedly delved into the mysteries of nature as
    they’ve judged the scientists’ entries.

    Very, very beautiful idea!

    Report abuse

  • Absolute genius!!!!

    Better than any school based ideas and one which involves scientists and children. The best people to teach science is scientists but with the right skills to be able to teach, and this method is not only aimed at those who wish to learn but those that wish to teach. A perfect coming together that, I hope, will become the next craze amongst 11 year olds which then has an effect on younger siblings. I think they have pitched this at the perfect age to involve the whole family, whether they want to or not. The discussions that it will evoke has no age barriers and although, I think, will have the greatest impact on younger siblings, will impact the whole family none the less. I don’t know many parents that can get in the way of fashion like they can in the way of schooling so bravo to Alan Alda and, I’m sure, his team.

    Report abuse

  • Sleep is like the standby mode on computers and appliances which awaken at the push of a button, much like religious people who awaken to atheism, this button is called the reality button

    Report abuse

  • 7
    Zacharias says:

    Sleep is a state whereby the brain is at a lower functioning state and can begin processes in which toxic by-products of metabolism can be carefully removed.

    This process is kinda like a janitor cleaning a school after school hours. If they were to clean during school hours, all the kids would make the job slow, difficult, and inefficient.

    Report abuse

  • 8
    RevJimBob says:

    We sleep because it is difficult and dangerous to try to make a living at night, and we might as well fill it using as little energy as possible, so we shut down as much as we safely can.

    Report abuse

Leave a Reply

View our comment policy.