Can Islam and Liberalism Coexist?

Aug 16, 2016

By Isaac Chotiner

One of the hopes that grew out of the Arab Spring was that a relatively moderate strain of Islamist politics could thrive in the region. Given the widespread prevalence of dictators and military-led regimes, and the violent radicals who oppose them in mirrored gruesomeness, groups like Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood were seen as potential alternatives. Five years later, however, the Arab Spring has devolved into a collection of bloody failures everywhere from Egypt to Syria. Another proposed model of Islamism—Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Turkey—was already giving way to autocracy well before a quashed coup attempt further entrenched Erdogan’s demagoguery.

These failures have raised the fraught question of whether Islam itself is partially to blame. Shadi Hamid, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, is the author of a new book, Islamic Exceptionalism: How the Struggle Over Islam Is Reshaping the World. The title gives some hint of his provocative analysis. As he writes, “If Islam is, in fact, distinctive in how it relates to politics, then the foundational divides that have torn the Middle East apart will persist, and for a long time to come.”

I recently spoke by phone with Hamid. During the course of our conversation, which has been edited and condensed for clarity, we discussed why liberals have trouble taking religion seriously, the future of Islamist politics in Turkey and Egypt, and what the rise of Donald Trump has meant for American Muslims.


Continue reading by clicking the name of the source below.

One comment on “Can Islam and Liberalism Coexist?”

  • 1
    fadeordraw says:

    This is a very good and interesting article – thanks. The mere juxtaposition that Mohamed was a leader and politician (and war monger I would argue), whereas Jesus did not rule or deal with those dilemmas, has some pertinence; somehow explaining why the secular approach to governance is problematic in the Middle East, why the Arab Spring came up short in Egypt and the increasingly autocratic, Islamic directed governance in Turkey; though autocracy seems to be the traditional model in Asia and Africa. Thanks again.



    Report abuse

Leave a Reply

View our comment policy.